Law Offices ofBrandon R. CeglianP.C. Attorneys group photo

Can gay marriage stop straight divorce?

Most Colorado readers are aware of the recent U.S. Supreme Court ruling that legitimizes same-sex marriage across the nation. In the aftermath of that groundbreaking decision, many people continue to have difficulty accepting the fact that marriage has been made possible to all, regardless of their gender. A recent divorce case serves as an example of the ire that can result in the wake of sweeping social change, as a family court judge refuses to grant a divorce to a heterosexual couple, citing the SCOTUS decision within his unusual ruling.

The spouses who came before the court were both in their 60s. In presenting their case to the court, they brought in seven witnesses, and submitted 77 different exhibits. The judge heard testimony and reviewed the evidence, but ultimately refused to grant the couple's divorce.

Within the ruling, the judge suggested that only the Supreme Court seemed to hold the authority to determine issues of marriage and that the jurisdiction of the state's courts was effectively preempted. Therefore, his ability to rule on matters of a contested divorce was also impeded. For the couple caught in the middle of the issue, the decision means that they will remain married against their will, at least for the time being. They may file for divorce again but will need to do so using different grounds.

This is an unusual outcome, and should not give Colorado spouses cause for concern about their own divorce case. That said, this is not the only case in which the Supreme Court decision on same-sex marriage has come into play. Some believe that this and similar instances are the result of individual judges using cases as a means of expressing their disapproval of the SCOTUS approach to gay marriage. Unfortunately, couples such as the one mentioned here are left caught in the middle of a debate to which they have no apparent connection.   

Source: dispatchtimes.com, "Tennessee judge refuses straight couple's divorce, citing SCOTUS gay marriage", Sept. 7, 2015

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
get Legal Help Now

Tell Us About Your Legal Issue

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information
disclaimer.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

close

Privacy Policy

Meet Our Attorneys

Attorney Brandon

Brandon Ceglian

Brandon Ceglian's practice focus is family law, landlord-tenant law / real estate, civil litigation, criminal / DUI, and collections. View Attorney Profile

Attorney Adam

J. Adam Beckman

Adam Beckman’s areas of focus are family law, adoptions and prenuptial agreements, and criminal law/DUI. View Attorney Profile

Dominic

Domenic Nicotra

Domenic Nicotra’s practices primarily in the areas of Landlord-Tenant, Family Law, Criminal, Protection Orders, and Civil Litigation. View Attorney Profile

Daniel

Daniel J. Zolnikov

Daniel Zolnikov practices in the areas of HOA, debt collections, landlord tenant, civil litigation and construction law. View Attorney Profile